LEGAL DILEMMA OF UNDOCUMENTED INDONESIAN MIGRANT WORKERS IN MALAYSIA: Compliance or Non-Compliance?

Trianah  Sofiani; Iqbal  Kamalludin; Norhamidah Binti Jarimal  @ Safri

doi:10.30631/alrisalah.v25i2.1998

Authors

Trianah Sofiani Universitas Islam Negeri KH. Abdurrahman Wahid Pekalongan
Iqbal Kamalludin Universitas Islam Negeri KH. Abdurrahman Wahid Pekalongan
Norhamidah Binti Jarimal @ Safri Universiti Malaysia Sabah

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.30631/alrisalah.v25i2.1998

Keywords:

Legal Compliance, Migrant Workers, Non-compliance, Undocumented

Abstract

This study explores the dilemmas faced by undocumented Indonesian migrant workers in deciding whether to comply with the law and examines the characteristics of their legal compliance and non-compliance through a multidisciplinary approach. Using a sociolegal method, interviews were conducted with purposively selected undocumented Indonesian migrant workers. Furthermore, a survey was conducted by administering questionnaires to 50 undocumented Indonesian migrant workers using online media channels. The findings reveal that undocumented Indonesian migrant workers who chose to disobey the law did so mainly because of their distrust in the legal system, rather than as a result of conscious or reflective reasoning. This is illustrated by the reasons for doubt, lack of funds, cost, fear of deportation, fear of punishment, fear of being blackmailed by officers, fear of being blocked, and fear of being unable to work abroad. Collaborative strategies and approaches based on the principles of justice, benefit, and trust are key to resolving the challenges facing undocumented Indonesian migrant workers. Fair implementation of laws and policies that provide tangible benefits to the community fosters trust in the legal system. This trust ultimately eliminates migrant workers' hesitation to comply with the law. These findings contribute to the efforts of policymakers, international organizations, and non-state actors to strengthen the governance of cross-border migration, particularly for migrant workers.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

ADBMI Foundation. “Tertangkap Di Perbatasan, PMI Nekat Pulang Kampung Lewat Jalur Ilegal,” March 20, 2024. https://www.adbmi.org/kabar/tertangkap-di-perbatasan-pmi-nekat-pulang-kampung-lewat-jalur-ilegal.

Adhi, Irawan Sapto. “Malaysia Temukan Perkampungan Ilegal Warga Indonesia Di Dalam Perkebunan Sawit, 130 Orang Ditahan.” kompas.com, February 18, 2024.

Amir, NZBM. “Migrasi Kultural Buruh Migran Indonesia Asal Nusa Tenggara Timur Ke Malaysia.” Migrantcare. migrantcare.net, 2016. https://migrantcare.net/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/migrasi-kultural_nor-zana.pdf.

Arisman, A, and R. K. Jaya. “Labour Migration in ASEAN: Indonesian Migrant Workers in Johor Bahru, Malaysia.” Asian Education and Development Studies, 2020. https://doi.org/10.1108/aeds-02-2019-0034.

Arohmi, A. F. “Legal Protection for Illegal Indonesian Workers in Malaysia.” Media of Law and Sharia, 2020. https://journal.umy.ac.id/index.php/mlsj/article/view/9186.

Badan Perlindungan Pekerja Migran Indonesia. “Laporan Tahunan Badan Perlindungan Pekerja Migran Indonesia 2023.” Jakarta, 2023.

Bailey, F. G., and James C. Scott. “Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance.” Pacific Affairs 60, no. 2 1987: 365. https://doi.org/10.2307/2758183.

Budiono, Eko. “Dubes RI Serukan WNI Ilegal Di Malaysia Manfaatkan Program Repatriasi Migran 2.0.” indonesia.go.Id, May 19, 2025.

Bustami, R., and I. S. Wekke. “Migrants In Nusantara: Indonesian and Malaysian Perspectives.” Journal of Nusantara Studies …, 2016.

Castles, S, M. A. Cubas, C Kim, and D Ozkul. “Irregular Migration: Causes, Patterns, and Strategies.” Global Perspectives on Migration …, 2012. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-4110-2_9.

Chin, L C. “A Strategy of Attrition through Enforcement: The Unmaking of Irregular Migration in Malaysia.” Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs, 2017. https://doi.org/10.1177/186810341703600204.

Clark, M, and J Pietsch. “Uneasy Neighbours: Indonesia–Malaysia Relations under Yudhoyono.” Aspirations with Limitations: Indonesia’s …, 2018.

Direktorat Jenderal Imigrasi, Humas. “Siaran Pers?: Dirjen Imigrasi Temui Ketua Pengarah Imigresen Malaysia Bahas Pekerja Migran Indonesia Di Malaysia – Direktorat Jenderal Imigrasi.” Kementerian Imigrasi dan Pemasyarakatan Direktorat Jenderal Imigrasi, January 17, 2024.

Djafar, F, and M K H Hassan. “Dynamics of Push and Pull Factors of Migrant Workers in Developing Countries: The Case of Indonesian Workers in Malaysia.” Journal of Economics and Behavioral …. researchgate.net, 2012.

Faradila, S H. Proses Kebijakan Indonesia Dalam Melindungi PMI Melalui One Channel System Dengan Malaysia 2019-2022. dspace.uii.ac.id, 2024. https://dspace.uii.ac.id/handle/123456789/51295.

Hamapu, Alamudin. “2.036 PMI Dideportasi Dari Malaysia Selama Periode Januari-Oktober 2024.” detik.com, October 9, 2024. https://www.detik.com/sumut/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-7580201/2-036-pmi-dideportasi-dari-malaysia-selama-periode-januari-oktober-2024.

Hamzah, I S, M R Sarifin, M S A Aziz, and ... “Malaysia as an Attraction of International Foreign Workers.” Journal Of Critical Reviews. ResearchGate.net, 2020. Https://Www.Researchgate.Net/Profile/Muhammad-Sarifin-2/Publication/343879425_Malaysia_As_Attraction_Of_International_Foreign_Workers/Links/5f463004a6fdcccc430742e7/Malaysia-As-Attraction-Of-International-Foreign-Workers.Pdf.

Hasan, R S D. Analisis Kebijakan Rekalibrasi Tenaga Kerja Di Malaysia Untuk Pekerja Migran Indonesia Ilegal Berdasarkan Memorandum of Understanding Indonesia Dan Malaysia …. repository.uki.ac.id, 2024. http://repository.uki.ac.id/15245/.

Hedström, P, and C Stern. “Rational Choice and Sociology.” The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, 2018. https://doi.org/10.1057/978-1-349-95189-5_2736.

Juliawan, Benny Hari. “Seeing Migration like a State: The Case of Irregular Indonesian Migrant Workers Deported from Malaysia.” Anti-Trafficking Review, no. 11 2018. https://doi.org/10.14197/atr.201218113.

Kanim Nunukan. “Admin Kantor Imigrasi Nunukan Tiga Pekerja Migran Indonesia (PMI) Non-Prosedural Berhasil Kembali Ke Indonesia Melalui Pos Lintas Batas Tradisional, Long Midang.” kanim nunukan, May 24, 2024. h

Kassim, A, and R. H. M. Zin. Policy on Irregular Migrants in Malaysia: An Analysis of Its Implementation and Effectiveness. econstor.eu, 2011.

Kelman, H C. “Further Thoughts on the Processes of Compliance, Identification, and Internalization.” Social Power and Political Influence, 2017.

Killias, O. “’ Illegal ’ Migration as Resistance: Legality, Morality and Coercion in Indonesian Domestic Worker Migration to Malaysia.” Asian Journal of Social Science, 2010.

Kudo, S. “Securitization of Undocumented Migrants and the Politics of Insecurity in Malaysia.” Procedia Environmental Sciences, 2013.

Kuli Bank. “5 Cara TKI Kosongan Dan Ilegal Bisa Pulang Ke Indonesia #tkimalaysia - YouTube.” YouTube, 2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7I058vbwAQM.

Low, C C. “Back for Good: Reforms in Legalization and Amnesty Programmes in Malaysia.” Bijdragen Tot de Taal-, Land-En Volkenkunde/Journal of …. brill.com, 2021.

Maharani, A. P., and A Maksum. “Kerja Sama Bilateral Indonesia-Malaysia Dalam Menangani Kasus TKI Ilegal Pada Masa Presiden Joko Widodo (2014-2019).” Proceedings …. download.garuda.kemdikbud.go.id, 2020.

Maksum, A. “Indonesia–Malaysia Relations from below: Indonesian Migrants and the Role of Identity.” South East Asia Research, 2022.

———. “Suffer to Survive: The Indonesian Illegal Workers' Experiences in Malaysia and Japan.” Journal of Social Research &Policy. academia.edu, 2017.

Montero, Guche. “Polisi Imigrasi Malaysia Tangkap Puluhan PMI Ilegal Asal NTT, Termasuk 9 Anak-Anak,” August 20, 2024.

Nagin, D. “Procedural Justice and Legal Compliance.” Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 2017.

Nasution, Anugrah. “PMI Ilegal Asal Aceh Hingga NTB Diamankan Di Sergai, Pulang Ke Indonesia Melalui Jalur Tikus - Tribun-Medan.Com.” Tribunnews, June 13, 2023.

Nengsi, F, and A Maksum. “Mainstreaming Realism Paradigm in Handling Illegal Immigrants in Malaysia.” Revista UNISCI. researchgate.net, 2020.

Noor, N M, and M N Shaker. “Perceived Workplace Discrimination, Coping and Psychological Distress among Unskilled Indonesian Migrant Workers in Malaysia.” International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 2017.

Novia, H, and S Djelantik. “Indonesia Diplomacy in Protecting the Rights of Indonesian Migrant Domestic Workers in Malaysia (2017-2022).” Insignia: Journal of International Relations. jos.unsoed.ac.id, 2024.

Palmer, W, and A Missbach. “Enforcing Labour Rights of Irregular Migrants in Indonesia.” Third World Quarterly, 2019. https://doi.org/10.1080/01436597.2018.1522586.

Pav?nik, M. “Radbruch, Gustav: His Formula and Concept of Law.” Encyclopedia of the Philosophy of Law and Social …, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-6519-1_218.

Prianto, A. L., A. R. Amri, and M. N. Ajis. “Governance and Protection of Indonesian Migrant Workers in Malaysia: A Study on Policy and Innovation Network.” JSEAHR, 2023.

PRIYANSYAH, A. “The Decision Making Analysis On One Channel System By Indonesian Government 2014-2018.” dspace.uii.ac.id, 2023.

Puteri, N. Kerja Sama Badan Pelindungan Pekerja Migran Indonesia (Bp2Mi) Dengan International Organization for Migration (Iom) Dalam Mencegah Pemberangkatan Calon …. repository.uinjkt.ac.id, 2023.

Putri, G E, K A K Mabruri, and ... “Implementation of Protection for Indonesian Migrant Workers in Malaysia in 2022-2023.” Dauliyah: Journal of …, 2025.

Rahayu, D. “Undocumented Indonesian Migrant Workers: Solution or Omission.” In International Conference on Social Science 2019 …. atlantis-press.com, 2019.

Rahyuni, Finta. “Kapal Bawa PMI Tenggelam Di Selat Malaka, Penumpang 4 Hari Terdampar-1 Tewas.” detik.com, 2024..

Rayhan, A, and R Azril. “The Urgency of Legal Protection for Indonesian Migrant Workers in Anticipation of Inter-Country Conflicts.” Publication of the International Journal …, 2025.

Rethanovagi, R, and R Rusdiyanta. “Penyelesaian Masalah Tenaga Kerja Indonesia (TKI) Ilegal Di Malaysia Melalui Multi Track Diplomacy Pada Periode 2011-2016.” Balcony, 2018.

Roy, S. “Theory of Social Proof and Legal Compliance: A Socio-Cognitive Explanation for Regulatory (Non) Compliance.” German Law Journal, 2021.

Santosa, I, A Rokhman, A Sabiq, and ... “Empowering Undocumented Indonesian Migrant Workers in Sarawak through Social Capital Enhancement.” Pakistan Journal of Life & …. pjlss.edu.pk, 2024.

Sargeant, E, E Antrobus, and D Platz. “Promoting a Culture of Fairness: Police Training, Procedural Justice, and Compliance.” Journal of Experimental Criminology, 2017.

Savelsberg, J J. “Max Weber´ s Formal and Substantive Rationality.” Recht Als Kultur? Beiträge Zu Max Webers …, 2017.

Savitri, H. “Smuggling of Illegal Indonesian Workers in Malaysia.” Al-Musthalah: Jurnal Riset Dan Penelitian …, 2024. https://journal.syamilahpublishing.com/index.php/musthalah/article/view/114.

Schofield, P. “Jeremy Bentham on Utility and Truth.” History of European Ideas, 2015.

Scholtz, H. “Rational Choice Theory in Comparative Sociology.” Comparative Sociology, 2015.

Setyorini, Virna P. “130 WNI Masuk Tanpa Izin Ditahan Imigrasi Malaysia - ANTARA News,” February 19, 2024.

———. “Malaysia Mulai Lagi Program Repatriasi Pekerja Migran Mulai 1 Maret - ANTARA News.” Antaranews, January 31, 2024.

Sibarani, R W. Determinants of Illegal Migration: The Case of Migrant Workers from East Java to Malaysia. books.google.com, 2018.

Simanullang, G, A C A Bangun, and I L M Utama. “Pengalaman Tenaga Kerja Indonesia Ilegal Di Malaysia: Sebuah Penelitian Fenomenologis.” Logos, 2023.

Sirait, N. N. “Legal Protection of International Labor Organization (ILO) and Indonesia Towards Indonesian Illegal Migrant Workers.” Second International Conference on Public Policy …, 2022.

Suadnyana, I Wayan Sui, and Simon Selly. “Lagi, PMI Ilegal Asal NTT Meninggal Di Malaysia,” June 13, 2024.

Surjono, G, S Usman, and ... “Pola Migrasi Pekerja Migran Sumenep Ke Arab Saudi Dan Malaysia Dan Dampaknya Bagi Lembaga Sosial Ekonomi Daerah Asal Migration Patterns of ….” Jurnal PKS …. download.garuda.kemdikbud.go.id, 2015.

Swedberg, R. “How to Use Max Weber’s Ideal Type in Sociological Analysis.” Journal of Classical Sociology, 2018.

Teichmann, F M J, and C Wittmann. “Compliance Cultures and the Role of Financial Incentives.” Journal of Financial Crime, 2024.

Tjitrawati, A T, and M K Romadhona. “Living beyond Borders: The International Legal Framework for Protecting Rights to Health of Indonesian Illegal Migrant Workers in Malaysia.” … of Migration, Health and Social Care, 2024.

Viqi, Ahmad. “Suwinah, PMI Yang Dianiaya Majikan Di Malaysia Akhirnya Pulang,” 2024.

Voss, Thomas. “James S. Coleman: Foundations of Social Theory.” In: Schlüsselwerke der Wirtschaftssoziologie, edited by Klaus Kraemer and Florian Brugger, 213–23. Wiesbaden: Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden, 2017.

Wahyudi, R. “Illegal Journey: The Indonesian Undocumented Migrant Workers to Malaysia.” Populasi, 2017. https://journal.ugm.ac.id/populasi/article/view/36202.

Waked, D I. “Jeremy Bentham and the Genesis of Law and Economics: An Alternative Narrative.” Research Handbook on Law and Utilitarianism, 2024.

Walters, G D. “Procedural Justice Perceptions, Legitimacy Beliefs, and Compliance with the Law: A Meta-Analysis.” Journal of Experimental Criminology 15, no. 3 2019: 341–72.