Freedom of Speech Without a Direction: Criticism of the Promotion of Freedom of Speech in Indonesia
PDF

Keywords

Freedom of Speech
Legal Vacuum
Synchronization
Strengthening Regulations

How to Cite

Sayuti, S., Effendi, G. N., & Yanti, I. . (2023). Freedom of Speech Without a Direction: Criticism of the Promotion of Freedom of Speech in Indonesia. Al-Risalah: Forum Kajian Hukum Dan Sosial Kemasyarakatan, 23(1), 121–144. https://doi.org/10.30631/alrisalah.v23i1.1389

Abstract

The attempt to equate freedom of speech with other rights, such as freedom of expression or opinion, is misguided because these rights have distinct realms concerning their promotion and resolution of legal violations. In practice, this misconception persists in Indonesia, where there is no specific law dedicated to regulating freedom of speech. Therefore, this study explored the factors that lead to legal vacuum for freedom of speech and provided solutions to overcome this vacuum. This study also assessed the various legal frameworks and practices concerning the promotion of freedom of speech in Indonesia after the 1998 Reform Era using a normative juridical approach. The result showed that legal vacuum in promoting the right to freedom of speech attributed to the conflicting priorities of human rights and the ambiguity surrounding the understanding of freedom of expression. It is important to synchronize laws and regulations regarding the rights belonging to freedom of expression and strengthen the associated regulation that specifically contain definitions, limitations, and ways of resolving violations of the law. This process provided a detailed legal direction or umbrella for efforts to promote freedom of speech.

https://doi.org/10.30631/alrisalah.v23i1.1389
PDF

References

Journals

Aditya, Zaka Firma, & Al-Fatih, Sholahuddin. “Indonesian Constitutional Rights: Expressing and Purposing Opinions on the Internet.” The International Journal of Human Rights, Oct 2020.

Ali, Mahrus. "Defamation Through Information Facilities and Electronic Transactions (Study of MK Decision No. 2/PUU-VII/2009)." Journal of the Constitution, Volume 7, Number 6, December 2010.

Alvat, Andi Pradikta. "Politics of Law Human Rights Protection in Indonesia." Daulat Hukum Journal, Volume 2 Issue 4, December 2019.

Anindyajati, Titis. "Limitation of the Right to Freedom of Speech on the Indonesian Constitutional Court Consideration." Indonesian Law Journal, Volume 14 No. 1, July 2021.

Anwar, Ahmad Syaifudin and Saputro, Lilik Agus. "Questioning the Article on Insulting the President in the Criminal Code: Between the Proportionality of the Primus Interpares Principle or the Setback of Democracy." Wicarana Journal of Law and Human Rights, Volume 2, Number 1, March 2023.

Apsari, Kirana. "Harmonization of the Right to Freedom of Opinion and Expression and Individual Rights to Reputation in a Human Rights Perspective." Journal of Kertha Negara, Vol. 9 No. 10 Year 2021.

Arta, Ketut Sedana. "Indonesian Politics in the Guided Democracy Period 1959-1966." Candra Sangkala's Journal, Vol 4, No 1, March 2022

Aydın-Aitchison, Andy and Mermutluoğlu, Ceren. “Mapping Human Rights to Democratic Policing Through the ECHR.” Security and Human Rights, 30, 2019.

Buana, Mirza Satria, Djafar, Wahyudi and Vikalista, Ellisa. "Problems and Construction of Regulatory Norms Restricting Freedom of Association in Indonesia." Journal of Law IUS QUIA IUSTUM, No. 3 Vols. 28, September 2021.

Chakim, M. Lutfi. “Freedom of Speech and The Role of Constitutional Courts: The Cases of Indonesia and South Korea.” Indonesia Law Review (2020) 2.

Dinata, Ari Wirya and Akbar, M. Yusuf. "Restrictions on the Right to Move Through Entry Prohibitions and Travel Restrictions During the Spread of the Covid-19 Virus According to International Law and Indonesian Law." Human Rights Journal, Volume 12, Number 2, August 2021.

Faiz, Pan Mohamad. “The Protection of Civil and Political Rights By The Constitutional Court of Indonesia.” Indonesia Law Review (2016) 2.

Fatmawati. "Protection of the Right to Freedom of Religion and Worship in the Indonesian Law State." Journal of the Constitution, Volume 8, Number 4, August 2011.

Fernando, Zico Junius, Pujiyono, Rozah, Umi, and Rochaeti, Nur. "The freedom of expression in Indonesia." Research Article Law, Criminology & Criminal Justice, Cogent Social Sciences, July 2022.

Gunatilleke, Gehan. “Justifying Limitations on the Freedom of Expression.” Human Rights Review, 22, 2021.

Hairi, Printer Jaya. "Contradictions to the Arrangement of Law that Lives in Society as Part of the Legality Principles of Indonesian Criminal Law." Rule of Law, Vol. 7, No. 1, June 2016.

Hasani, Ismail, and Halili. "Human Rights and Constitutionality Issues of Blasphemy Law in Indonesia." Journal of the Constitution, Volume 19, Number 2, June 2022.

Hasbi, Rahil Muhammad. "The Role of Public and Private Spaces in Producing and Consuming Social Space, Case Study of Burgazada Island, Istanbul, Turkey." Vitruvian: Journal of Architecture, Building & Environment, Vol. 5, No. 1, 2015.

Indrajat, Himawan. "Guided Democracy A Conception of Soekarno's Thoughts About Democracy." Journal of Sociology, Vol. 18, no. 1, 2016.

Iqbal, Mahathir Muhammad. "Quo Vadis Human Rights Enforcement in Indonesia." Al-Himayah Journal, Volume 3 Number 1 March 2019.

Irmawanti, Noveria Devy and Nawawi Arief, Barda. "Urgency of Goals and Guidelines for Criminal Justice in the Context of Updating the Criminal Law Criminal System." Journal of Indonesian Legal Development, Master of Law Study Program, Volume 3, Number 2, Year 2021

Juliana, Sufiana. "Restrictions on Freedom of Expression in Social Media: Evaluation of the Electronic Information and Transaction Law in the Perspective of Human Rights." Padjadjaran Law Review, Volume 6, December 2018.

Kharlie, Ahmad Tholabi. “Human Rights in Indonesian Constitutional Amendments.” Cita Hukum Journal, Vol. I No. June 1, 2013.

Kurniawan, Arief Rianto and Primawardani, Yuliana. "Proportionality of Human Rights Restrictions in Article 28 of the Law on the Eradication of Criminal Acts of Terrorism." Journal of Indonesian Legislation, Vol. 16 No.1 - March 2019.

Mareta, Josefhin. "Application of Restorative Justice Through Fulfillment of Restitution for Victims of Child Crime." Journal of Indonesian Legislation, Vol 15 No.4 - December 2018.

Marwandianto, and Nasution, Hilmi Ardani. “The Rights to Freedom of Opinion and Expression in The Corridors of Articles 310 and 311 of the Criminal Code.” Jurnal HAM, Volume 11, No. 1, April 2020.

Matompo, Osgar S. "Restrictions on Human Rights in the Perspective of an Emergency Situation." Journal of Media Hukum, Volume 21 No. 1, June 2014.

Nasution, Latipah. “The Right to Freedom of Opinion and Expression in Public Spaces in the Digital Age.” Law and Justice Bulletin, Volume 4 Number 3, 2020.

Notanubun, Peiroll Gerard. "Juridical Review of Freedom of Speech in the Provisions of Article 27 paragraph (3) of Law Number 11 of 2008 concerning ITE in Relation to Article 28 of the 1945 Constitution." Platform for Justice, Journal of Legal Studies, Edition: May - November 2014.

Nugraha, Harry Setya. "The Idea of Re-Amending the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia." Lex Renaissance, No. 1 Vol. 3, January 2018.

Priyanto, Grandis Ayuning, and Sardi, Martinus. "The Urgency of Protecting Netizens in Freedom of Speech on Social Media." Media of Law and Sharia, Volume 2, Number 1, 2020.

Purnomo, Yudi, Lubis, Mira S., Nurhamsyah, M., and Mustikawati. "The Concept of Student Public Open Space as a Liaison between Units at Tanjungpura University." Langkau Betang, Vol. 1/No. 1/2014.

Putra, Muhammad Amin. "Existence of State Institutions in the Enforcement of Human Rights in Indonesia." Fiat Justicia Journal of Legal Studies, Volume 9 No. 3, July-September 2015.

Radjab, Syamsuddin. "Differences between human rights regimes and criminal regimes." Al-Daulah, Vol. 3, No. 2, December 2014.

Rochman, Saepul, Akmal, Haerul and Andriansyah, Yaffi Jananta. "Defamation Through Social Media: Comparison of Positive and Islamic Criminal Law." Dictum: Journal of Sharia and Law, Volume 19 Number 1 July 2021.

Romli, Lili. "New Format of the House of Representatives After the Amendment to the 1945 Constitution." Politica, Vol. 3, No. 2, Nov. 2012.

Roqib, Muhammad, Anugraha, Happy, Putra, Sutrisno, Noris, Anwar, and Ambarita, Hotma Parlindungan. "The Right to Freedom of Expression and Opinion in Indonesia and in the United States." Legal Perspectives, Vol 20 No. May 1, 2020.

Saitya, Ida Bagus Subrahmaniam. "Organization of Human Rights in Indonesia." SINTESA: Journal of Social and Political Sciences, Volume 8, Number 2, September 2017.

Sangsuvan, Kitsuron. “Balancing Freedom of Speech on the Internet Under International Law.” North Carolina Journal of International Law and Commercial Regulation, 39, 2014.

Saptohadi, Satrio. "The Ebb and Down of Press Freedom in Indonesia." Journal of Legal Dynamics, Vol. 11 No. 1, January 2011.

Sari, Putri Tunjung. “The Implementation of Freedom of Speech Principles in Indonesian Press Regulations.” International Journal of Communication and Society, Vol. 2, No. 1, June 2020

Sears, Alan. “Protecting Freedom of Expression over the Internet: An International Approach.” Notre Dame Journal of International & Comparative Law, Vol. 5, 2015.

Silva, Diego Steven, and Smith, Maxwell J. “Limiting Rights and Freedoms in the Context of Ebola and Other Public Health Emergencies: How the Principle of Reciprocity Can Enrich the Application of the Siracusa Principles.” Health and Human Rights Journal, 17 , No. 1 2015.

Staples, Clara. “Freedom of Speech In Indonesian Press: International Human Rights Perspective.” Brawijaya Law Journal, v.3 n.1, 2016

Sturges, Paul. “Limits to Freedom of Expression? Considerations Arising from The Danish Cartoons Affair.” IFLA Journal, 32 (2006).

Sulistyanta. "Implications of Criminal Acts Outside the Criminal Code in Criminal Procedure Law (Case Studies at the Synchronization Level)." Journal of Legal Dynamics, Vol. 13 No. 2 May 2013.

Supriyanto, Bambang Heri. "Law Enforcement Regarding Human Rights (HAM) According to Positive Law in Indonesia." Journal of AL-AZHAR INDONESIA SERIES OF SOCIAL PRANATA, Vol . 2, No. 3, March 2014.

Susanto, Efendi. "The Fourth Precept of Pancasila and the Current Indonesian Democratic Climate." Legal Issues, Volume 50 No.1, January 2021.

Syafriadi, and Susanti, Heni. "Conception and Implementation of Freedom of Speech and Expression in Indonesian Legal Studies." International Journal of Innovation, Creativity and Change, Volume 10, Issue 4, 2019.

Syahlan, S. “Effective and Efficient Synchronization in the Harmonization of Indonesian Regulations.” Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 1(1), 2021.

Tibaka, Leli & Rosdian. “The Protection of Human Rights in Indonesian Constitutional Law after the Amendment of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia.” Fiat Justitia, Volume 11 Number 3, July-September 2017

Yusdiyanto. "The Philosophical Meaning of the Fourth Precepts of Pancasila in the Democratic System in Indonesia." Fiat Justicia Journal of Law, Volume 10 Issue 2, April-June 2016.

Zanzibar, Zen. "The Indonesian Constitutional System in the Post Amendment of the 1945 Constitution." Sriwijaya Law Review, Vol. 2 Issue 1, January (2018).

Books

Alexander, Larry. Is There A Right to Freedom of Expression. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2005.

Amiruddin & Asikin, Zainal. Introduction to Legal Research Methods. Jakarta: Raja Grafindo Persada, 2012.

Aprita, Serlika, and Hasyim,Yonani. Law and Human Rights. First Edition. Jakarta: Media Discourse Partners, 2020.

Atmasasmita, Romli. Integrative Law Theory, Yogyakarta: Genta Publishing, 2012.

Contrast. 4-Year Evaluation Record of the Performance of the Government of Joko Widodo-Jusuf Kalla Indonesian Cabinet Work, Human Rights Sector, Human Rights is Not a Priority. Jakarta: Kontras, 2018.

Manan, Bagir. Press Public Politics. Jakarta: Press Council, 2014.

Marzuki, Peter Mahmud. Legal Research. Jakarta: Kencana Prenada Media Group, 2011.

Mestika, Zed. Library Research Methods. Jakarta: Bogor Indonesia Foundation, 2004.

Muladi. Human Rights, Nature, Concepts and Implications. Bandung: Rafika Aditama, 2005.

Sayuti. Freedom of Opinion According to the Indonesian Law State. Yogyakarta: Gading, 2021.

Soekanto and Mamuji, Sri. Normative Legal Research, A Brief Overview. Jakarta: Rajawali Press, 1990.

UNESCO. Toolkit on Freedom of Opinion and Expression for Information Activists. Paris: UNESCO, 2003.

Yamin, Muhammad. Preparatory Manuscripts of the 1945 Constitution. Jakarta: Siguntang, 1971.

Other Documents

CNN Indonesia. "Munarman FPI about 6 Soldiers Killed: That's Extra Judicial Killing." https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20201207174707-12-579047/ munarman-fpi-soal-6-laskar-tewas-itu-extra-judicial-killing, December 7, 2020.

CNN Indonesia. "Those snared by the ITE Law in 2020: Said Didu to Munarman." https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20201224150640-12-586053/they-yang-dijerat-uu-ite-di-2020-said-didu-til-munar man, December 24, 2020, access January 8, 2023.

Detik news. "Haikal Hassan's Explanation about the Dream of Meeting the Messenger of Allah." https://news.detik.com/berita/d-5829011/penhasilan-haikal-hassan-soal-mimpi-meet-rasulullah, 26 November 2021, access 7 February 2023.

HAM RI. "Komnas HAM: Violations of Freedom of Expression and Opinion Occur in Digital Space." https://www.komnasham.go.id/index.php/news/2022/1/17/2065/komnas-ham-pelanggaran-kebebasan-berekspresi-dan-berpendapat-terjadi-di-ruang-digi tal.html, access January 3, 2023.

Harel, Alon. “Freedom of Speech.” https://www.researchgate. net/publications/ 228321980, 28 May 2014.

Harisman. “Protection of Human Rights in the Amendment of the 1945 Constitution of The Republic of Indonesia.” Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Law and Human Rights, 2020.

KBBI. https://kbbi.web.id/spoke.

KBBI. https://kbbi.web.id/dapat.

KBBI. https://kbbi.web.id/expression.

KBBI. https://kbbi.web.id/kata.

KBBI. https://kbbi.web.id/public.

Human Rights Committee. “Freedoms of Opinion and Expression.” 102nd Session, Geneva, 11-29 July 2011.

Johnson, John W. "The Role of Free Media." Office of International Information Programs US Department of States, 2001.

Lawson and Schermers. “Leading Cases of the European Court of Human Rights.” Ars Aequi Libri, Nijmegen, 1997.

Martini, Ni Made. "The Impact of Ratification of the Draft Criminal Code (RUU KUHP) on Women and Vulnerable Groups." Material Presented at the 2022 National Penal Code Reform Consultation, Department of Criminology, FISIP, University of Indonesia, 22-23 June 2022.

Parliana, Dewi. "Dichotomy of Public and Private Spaces in Urban Communities (2002 Literature Study)." Research, National Institute of Technology, November 2002.

Shattuck, John, and Risse, Mathias. “Reimagining Rights & Responsibilities in the United States: Freedom of Speech and Media.” Carr Center for Human Rights Policy Harvard Kennedy School, Harvard University, 2021.

Sitompul, Sofyan. “Maintaining the Authority and Dignity of the Judiciary Through Trial and Security Protocols.” https://www.mahkamahagung.go.id/id/artikel/4475.

Stjernfelt, F., and Lauritzen, AM. “What Is Freedom of Speech?” Chapter 1, 2020, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-25968-6_1

YLBHI. "One Year of Jokowi-Ma'ruf: Trampling Law and Human Rights." https://ylbhi.or.id/formasi/siaran-pers/satu-tahun-jokowi-maruf-menginjak-injak- Hukum-dan-hak-asasi-human, October 2020

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Copyright (c) 2023 Sayuti Sayuti, Ghina Nabilah Effendi, Illy Yanti

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.